The Wine Log Blog

A blog of my wine tastings and reviews for anybody who likes wine or just wants a good wine recommendation. This site will be especially useful to those in Ontario, Canada shopping at the LCBO. You can search my reviews by using the search bar located at the top of the page. ----Note: Try refreshing the page if you don't see anything new!----

Saturday, November 15, 2008

Niagara Wine Tour 2008

This year I revisited some wineries I’ve been to in the past as well as one winery that I haven’t tried anything from before, Fielding Estate. I was especially interested to try wines from the unusually hot and dry 2007 vintage and see how winemakers had adapted their techniques to it.

Peninsula Ridge
The wines are usually pretty solid here and reasonably priced. They are known for producing one of the better Sauvignon Blancs in Ontario so I wanted to see what they came up with for 2007.

2007 Sauvignon Blanc
Typical gooseberry and light grassy aromas with lemon and grapefruit lending a sour and bitter edge. A little thin on the palate and the sharp on the finish. A blend of three vineyards. $14.75 87

2007 AJ Lepp Vineyard Sauvignon Blanc
This is from one of the three vineyards that goes in to the standard Sauvignon Blanc. The vineyard is located on the lakeshore, not the Bench. Less green and has more weight than the regular bottling, it almost reaches the tropical fruit (pineapple, passion fruit) that you would get in a good New Zealand example, no doubt a sign of the vintage. Mandarin peel and a rich nutty minerality. Slight musty notes. I’m still sticking to NZ and France for my Sauvignon Blanc, but this wasn’t bad. $18.95 89

2006 Fumé Blanc
A light butterscotch bouquet reveals the oak treatment that this Sauvignon Blanc received. There is too much raw oak (plank) in the finish, but there is some balancing done by the ripe fruit (apricot jam). Still not a treatment that I like for the varietal, and certainly not one any fans of clean herbaceous, mineral Sauvignon Blanc will appreciate either. $26.95 87

2007 Shiraz
I’m natural skeptical of using a grape that comes from a warm Mediterranean climate in Ontario. All too often Shiraz/Syrah from Niagara disappoints with under-ripe thin wines, but in 2007 it was possible to almost reach the grape’s potential (but how often will that happen?). This Shiraz had some of the volatile high notes of a cooler climate (raspberry), but surprisingly opened up quickly to show some black pepper, blueberry, and light bacon! Finish was weak, but I was surprised it had some real Shiraz character. Decent value. $14.95 88

2007 Cabernet Franc Icewine
I was surprised to see that they had managed a red icewine with the late arrival of the freeze in 2007. Apparently they had a brief window in January that was just enough. Smells like a Vidal icewine at first, you really have to dig to get any Cabernet Franc character. Strawberry jam finish with faint tobacco noticeable in the empty glass. Not cloying, but not anywhere close to the Cab Franc icewine they have produced before and the price reflects this. $34.95 for 375 mL 89

Angels Gate
The smells of ongoing fermentations were strong enough to make it difficult to really smell the wines well.

2007 Sussreserve Riesling
A little slate and lemon drop with some greenness on the finish. Yeasty (lees) mid-palate with a clean lingering lemony finish. The moderately high acid doesn’t lend itself to sipping without food. Decent value. $13.95 88

2007 Gewürztraminer
Not as floral as I was expecting, mostly spice and lychee nut. Not bitter, but not much in the way of Gewürz to distinguish it. Interesting ginger ale aftertaste. Musty fruit and more lychee nut than fruit. The 2005 was better. $15.75 87

Fielding Estate Winery
Nice eco-barn look with a well lit tasting bar thanks to the large windows. Unpretentious staff and no fermentation smells leaking in from the winery side (though you can see the vats). $2 for 3 tastings, waived with purchase.

2007 Gewürztraminer Reserve
Nice clean floral aromas (white flowers), light lychee and mild citrus. Well delineated flavours mirror the nose. There is some of the thickness you’d expect from a decent Gewürz. Not overdone or bitter; well balanced and clean. $24 90

2007 Riesling
Honey and lemon candy on the nose. This is also very clean and has a good balance of acid and ripeness (off-dry). Light minerality. $16 90

2007 Pinot Gris
This was a winner for sure, so much so that it was the only wine I bought during the outing. Light pink hue from the skin contact. Poached pear and apple skin with a floral must undertone. Not overly complex, but it was silky and mouth filling with just enough acid to offset the residual sugar. Ripe and tasty. $18 91

Malivoire
Some smells of fermentation and fruit flies in the tasting room are irritating. You can have the $5 tasting fee waived if you sign up for the customer list.

2007 Pinot Gris
Apple and light melon with lemon oil on the finish. Good weight to it like the Fielding Pinot Gris, but not as well rounded or crowd pleasing (more acid). $19.80 89

2006 Moira Vineyard Chardonnay
A little too oaky for my taste: butterscotch, with mineral, hazelnut peaking through. Vanilla cream aftertaste. Over priced. $36.80 89

2007 Gewürztraminer
This Gewürztraminer packs a walloping 14% alcohol punch thanks to the vintage and late harvest. 42 hour cold soak on the skins to extract the character from the tiny sun baked berries. Perfect varietal nose, most distinctly Gewürz of the whole day: reeks of roses and ripe lychee. Love the nose! The alcohol does come through on the palate with a little spice. Nice weight of course. Minus points only for the price and alcoholic heat. The price can be justified by the low yields though. $21.90 for 375 mL 92

2006 Pinot Noir
Too much vanilla from the oak with cloves and pine needle notes too. Phenolic, almost aggressive high notes. Astringent finish. Not a fan of this style. $26.80 86

2006 Moira Vineyard Pinot Noir
This has more Pinot character than the regular bottling: earthy beets, cherry, and the oak is more integrated. There is even a little elegance. Potential to age, but still not my idea of Pinot Noir and the price is not reflective of the quality. $42 89

2006 Gamay
Tried this one not expecting much difference from the disappointing 2005, but I was pleasantly surprised. Slight cheesiness (maybe banana skin) that blows off quickly to reveal strawberry/cherry, and some black fruit and floral elements lending depth. The oak, I’m told, was used in a more restrained fashion in 2006 which I think was a good call (this was a fault in the 2005). They also bled off some juice to concentrate flavour (the French term is saignee). There is even a distinct leathery note in the mid-palate that I liked. Reminds me of a good Beaujolais (think Morgon). I can’t believe it, but I actually liked a Gamay from Ontario! And so did the critics: “This is one of Ontario's best Gamays ever, with fragrant bing cherries, coconut and cedar notes, showing lots of depth and endless sweet-edged fruit” 90 Gordon Stimmell, Toronto Star. $16.80 89

2006 Late Harvest Gewürztraminer
What a disaster. They opened two bottles, but both were similar. Sharp oxidized nose of Madeira and apple cider. Good acid and not overly sweet, but this wasn’t even remotely recognizable as Gewürztraminer. And this after the amazing 2007 Gewürztraminer. What happened here? $25.90 for 375 mL (yikes!) 74

Henry of Pelham
Same cozy cottage like, and slightly smelly basement tasting room as always.

2007 Off Dry Reserve Riesling
Nice petrol/slate, mineral and lemon. Clean and simple. Lingering lemon aftertaste. Pretty standard, nothing stands out here. $15.95 89

2006 Cabernet Franc
Barrel toast is obvious with strawberry, tobacco, and a little greenness (within reason though). Bitter finish. Once again nothing special but no real faults. Price is good. $14.25 88

2005 Reserve Baco Noir
Lots of vanilla (new oak), herbaceous, sharp raspberry, slight metallic sourdough character that will put off some tasters for sure. Not particularly interesting. Pelham is known for its Baco, but I’m not terribly fond of this vintage. $24.95 86

Note: It seems to me that Pelham, like a lot of other wineries, is a bit stuck in the past. Their wines are all pretty decent, no real faults, but that isn’t very interesting. As the bar gets raised in Niagara those that don’t push the envelope a bit and keep doing the same are going to get left behind. Their tasting room, though quaint, mirrors the wines – they both need some updating!

Labels:

Saturday, December 29, 2007

Le Clos Jordanne: 2005s

Overall I was slightly less impressed with the 2005 vintage than I was the 2004, but found that the same high quality remained. I’m sure that with some cellaring these will come together nicely. I thought that there was a bit of sourness in the nose coming from elevated volatile acidity, but far from the point of being a flaw. Maybe this sourness was what David Lawrason was referring to in his Toronto Life blog, “…they’re youthfully nervy, bordering on sour and tannic”. I will refer to Lawrason’s scores throughout as DL score: abbreviated tasting notes. I read his notes after I had assigned my scores so it’s interesting to see where we agree or differ.

Village Reserve Chardonnay
Creamy oak, tropical fruit (pineapple), biscuit, butterscotch, hazelnut, good green apple acidity and mineral linger on the finish. With some air I smell faint lanolin. Pretty good value by Niagara standards. DL 90: very good value, pineapple, lemon, butterscotch, lemony acidity and hazelnut cream on the finish. Our notes are surprisingly close other than the green apple acidity I got that he noted as lemon. $25 89

Village Reserve Pinot Noir
A bit mushroomy at first, candied cherry, mild oak spice, watery mid-palate and finish. I noticed some red apple skin, almost like the apple cider note which I get frequently in Bourgogne. The finish is slightly short. For me the 2004 was better (I scored it 89). DL 88: black cherry-currant nose, cedar, chocolate, touch of mint, grippy, dry and sourish, very good length. Our notes couldn’t be more different (especially the length), but we scored the wine similarly. $25 87

La Petite Pinot Noir

I noticed a funky, almost cheesy, aroma that blew off with some vigorous swirling. I found it slightly floral with sweet perfumy strawberry, rhubarb, and sour cherry. As expected it was the most delicate (some might say feminine) of the lot. There are light vanilla tones which give way to a floral spiciness, somewhat like Grains of Paradise. Nice finish with lingering fruit. The 2004 was better. I think the growing conditions in 2005 did not bring out the best aspects of this vineyard. DL 88: “Nose is lifted, very spicy and savoury with ripe sour cherry (not big black cherry) and a touch of earthy beetroot character”. $35 89

Claystone Terrace Pinot Noir
Immediately I sense more depth and black fruit than the previous wines. There is a subdued gamey note, plum and black cherry, and beetroot, with a mineral core that underpins the fruit. To me it’s not particularly complex at this point but still good. Gordon Stimmell writes in the Toronto Star “This Niagara winery's pinots rival Burgundy's best. The nose shows classic beetroot, vanilla wafer and big black cherry. The vanilla-laced flavours unfold with black cherry and earthy wood smoke. Overall, rich, suffusive and delicious. 92” DL 90: cherry-raisin, plum, gentle spice, nougat, leather, chocolate, fairly tannic and blunt. Looks like my score falls right in between. $35 91

Grand Clos Pinot Noir
For me it has a silky texture and depth that clearly separates it from the other wines. I would say it’s the best of the lot. It is rounder and fuller in the mouth and as I’ve noticed before great length. Not as dark as the Claystone; the fruit is a balance of red and black. Sweet cherry, red apple/cider, savoury notes, perhaps a bit sour at the moment. The sweet perfume lingers on and saturates my senses when I exhale through my nose. Some minerality to round things up too. I noticed some barnyard while sniffing the dregs of the glass. It has the power of the Claystone with some of the sweet perfume of La Petite. DL 92: black cherry, currant, cedar, meat, mint, some chocolate, dense and elegant, outstanding length. Again our ratings are within 1 point of each other. $60 93

There was has been some debate between tasters as to whether the 2005 Claystone or the Grand Clos is better, but personally I think the Grand Clos had more depth, better texture, and the finish lasted much longer. The Grand Clos is better now and it will be even better with some time in the cellar. However, considering that the Claystone is almost half the price of the Grand Clos the quality to price ratio makes the Claystone the better buy of two.


I can’t wait to taste the 2006s from the bottle!

Labels: ,

Sunday, December 16, 2007

Le Clos Jordanne Intro: 2004s

Up until I tried the wines from Clos Jordanne I was consistently unimpressed with the quality of the Pinot Noir coming from Niagara. I always thought that there was a lot of unrealized potential and couldn’t understand why so many watery, boring wines were being produced; after all, the climate and soil seem well suited to Pinot and the latitude is close that of Burgundy. I was hoping at some point someone would get serious and raise the bar, but I wasn’t expecting it anytime soon.

For me, as for most people who tried the first released vintage (2004), tasting the wines of Clos Jordanne for the first time marked a new era for Niagara wine. I was excited that someone was finally making Pinot Noir here that I actually liked, and better yet the wines had distinct terroir. From what I’ve read I think most wine critics would agree that Le Clos Jordanne has set the benchmark for the varietal in Niagara.

My favourite press quote from the first release:
“The room was buzzing—Bachelder’s rich baritone couldn’t corral us. That wine was unlike any the province had ever produced. I knew at that moment that a page in On­tario’s wine history had just turned.” The Grape’s Progress, Toronto Life, David Lawrason.
You can find the rest of the article here.

For more rave reviews.

The wine maker, Thomas Bachelder, is an enthusiastic proponent of terroir so I think it’s appropriate to start with my general impressions of the distinguishing characteristics I have noticed between the different vineyards.

The Pinot Noir Vineyards

Talon Ridge: The grapes from this vineyard comprise a majority of the Village Reserve. Not the most refined of the vineyards, but by no means poor in any way. I frequently get cherry cola, a faint floral perfume, and an underlying earthy minerality.

The Single Vineyard Pinot Noirs

La Petite Vineyard: This vineyard is a favourite of mine, although those who like bigger darker pinot may overlook it. It is the most elegant and floral with the fruit leaning toward the red spectrum.

Claystone Terrace: This vineyard is often a favourite because of its burly frame and extract leaning toward black fruits and a strong mineral backbone. Big, but with some poise.

Le Clos Jordanne: Mineral, spice and earth with well defined fruit. Almost as big and dark as the Claystone, but with more perfume. Mix of the elegance of La Petite with the brawn of Claystone.

The flagship Grand Clos

Le Grand Clos: This is a block of Le Clos Jordanne that was kept separate for its special qualities. The thing that struck me immediately in every vintage I tried was the amazing length of the finish and the velvety texture. Similar in character to Le Clos Jordanne, but with added complexity. The wine maker and numerous wine critics have also remarked on the exceptional palate persistence of this cuvee.

Not too surprisingly my impressions of the various vineyards match up very well with what other wine writers and the winemaker have noted, which goes to show that these differences are quite obvious and don’t require a wine expert to tell the difference. All the wines are vinified the same way and a mix of Pinot clones is used to remove the effects of clonal variation, so it is safe to say the unique characteristics are derived in the vineyard. This is probably one of the best examples of the affect terroir can have in Niagara.

The 2004s
Both of the Village Reserve wines tipped the scales at around 14% alcohol.

Village Reserve Chardonnay
Oak is evident (vanilla, maple syrup) but not overpowering because there is plenty of acid to balance things out. Nutty notes of pecan/cashew, citrus (grapefruit), with good weight. Not bad value when compared to other wines in the Niagara Chardonnay class. Tony Aspler gives this 4/5 stars: caramel, vanilla, orange peel, peach. $25 89

Village Reserve Pinot Noir
Not overly complex or weighty, but there is a nice minerality, structure, and concentration I have never seen in a Niagara Pinot in this price range. Toasty cracker, sour cherry, and best of all a bit of that lovely Pinot perfume I crave (floral, violets). The oak is not overdone here, only 30% new I’m told. Tony Aspler gives this 4.5/5 stars: earthy, beetroot, violet, raspberry. $25 89

In Brief -
Press reviews for the other single vineyard ($35) and Grand Clos ($60) Pinots were very positive. La Petite was scored 91 by Wine Access: lightest and most elegant of the single vineyard Pinots, floral perfume, cherry-cranberry, almost silky. I couldn’t agree more. The Claystone Terrace was rated 4.5-5/5 by Aspler: minerally, raspberry, mint, firmly structured. The Clos Jordanne rated a 90 by Wine Access: ripe cherry, moving into medium body range. Le Grand Clos was rated 93 by Wine Access: better fruit definition, “the best length I can remember from Pinot Noir in Canada or many other places”, beetroot. Gordon Stimmel of the Toronto Star also rated Le Grand Clos a 93 and proclaimed that it was the best Canadian Pinot Noir he had ever tasted. Of all the reviews I agree with David Lawrason’s (Wine Access) notes the most, our palates seem to be quite similar.

Next Post: Le Clos Jordanne 2005s

Below is a picture I took of the open-top oak fermentors at Le Clos Jordanne .

Labels: ,

Sunday, November 25, 2007

Niagara Wine Tour 2007 Part 3

I visited Daniel Lenko Estate the same day as Hidden Bench and Tawse on the second day of the tour. All three of these wineries are on the Bench west of St. Catharines away from the bustle of Niagara on the Lake. The more I tour around Niagara the more it seems that the wineries located on or near the Bench are producing the most exciting wines in Ontario.

Hidden Bench
This winery is not on the Ontario Wine Route map and the parking lot was almost empty, which is not a reflection on the wines by any means. The green barn like exterior of the tasting room is set amongst the vines of the Locust Lane Vineyard and has a secluded feel. The winery just opened its doors in May 2007, but as Stimmell noted in the Toronto Star the portfolio is aimed high in terms of quality and price. There is a tasting fee of $10 for a flight of three.

2005 Estate Chardonnay
This is a blend of grapes from Rosomel and Locust Lane Vineyards. Very clean nose with only minimal oak. Notes of coconut, pear, brown sugar, and grapefruit. Very ripe with decent concentration and a higher than normal alcohol of 14% which lends some weight to the palate. Winery notes say ‘quince’, I can agree with that. Nice balance of acid/fruit and oak. $30 90

2005 Vielles Vignes Chardonnay
This is 100% Rosomel fruit. I’m told the vines are 32 years old, hence the vielles vignes. More oak influence than the Estate Chard with apple, butter, caramel, and some floral notes (white flowers), and light hazelnut. Maybe needs some time to integrate the oak. 91 in the Toronto Star: smoky apple (it looks like we agree). $40 91

2005 Estate Pinot Noir
This Pinot comes across in a high strung, almost aggressive, manner. It lacks some elegance and concentration, which unfortunately is not uncommon of most Ontario Pinot. A lot of sweet cherry and strawberry jam, strong high notes of a spicy floral nature, and mint. Pale ruby colour looks a bit watery. Some earthy beetroot nuances. Not bad (I guess they did the best with the grapes they had), but I thought it was a little out of whack. 91 in the Toronto Star, Stimmell notes: wild strawberry, smoky beetroot, black cherry. I agree with the characterization but not the score. $35 88

2005 Terroir Caché
Too much toast for me here which accentuates the green elements and kills the nose. I’m told it is a medium+ toast. Peeking out from under the burnt wood is some nice ripe red fruit on the palate. The style reminds me of Creekside’s reds with its big smoky concentrated style. On the plus side it has a great round mouthfeel and lots of weight. The finish is sweetish with cedar notes. Not at all my favourite style, but I can’t fault it for that. Stimmell gives it 91 and notes: smoky cigar box, blackberry and cherry, long and rich. $35 89

Tawse
This biodynamic winery boasts a 6 level gravity fed design and the tasting room is open to most of the levels which means you get the sent of fermentation to accompany your experience (and the occasional fruit fly). Nicely designed, this winery is obviously marketing to a similar crowd as Hidden Bench, it also has $10/3 tasting flights.

2004 Beamsville Bench Chardonnay
Caramel, roasted nuts, and sweet biscuity bouquet with pineapple coming across in the aftertaste. Round and simple with good acid to hold up to the oak. Nice silky mouthfeel. It didn’t hold up too well after some time in the glass. $42 89

2005 Beamsville Bench Chardonnay
This ripe Chard has a whopping 14.3% alcohol which isn’t that noticeable, but does add some heft. Butterscotch, green apple, pie spice, and unfortunately a hint of green sappiness that detracts from the overall package. More oak than I’d like to see, though there is balancing acid and fruit. It is rounder than the 2004 but overall I found it kind of boring and because of the oak. I’m not sure what food I’d pair with this. $47 88

2004 Robyn’s Block Chardonnay
The oak is not dominant and the buttery aspects are balanced with clean fruit and mineral notes. I get stones, spring water/mineral water, pineapple, very faint floral elements, and interesting savoury notes. The finish is really long, always a trait of good Chardonnay. Solid wine with much more food pairing potential than the 2005 Beamsville Bench Chard. $48 92

That wraps up the Niagara tasting notes for another year or so. Overall I noticed less heavy barrel toasting than previous years, which was definitely a good thing, however most of the reds were still lack lustre for me, and those that were outstanding were too pricey. The standout wines were all Chardonnays, which to me indicates that it has a bright future here. The Chardonnay I tasted was not only good for Niagara, but for anywhere else in the world in my opinion.

This tour of Niagara got me thinking about the industry and its direction, so I will close with some of my musings. As I tasted I thought to myself that in order to up the quality and profile of wines from Niagara wine makers need to focus on what does well in the region. Niagara needs to be known for doing something well and making Cabernet Sauvignon that hasn’t ripened properly will not cut it. The same goes for varietials from Rhône or Southwest France as far as I’m concerned. I don’t care if Syrah is popular at the moment, or that Jancis Robinson thinks Lenko’s Syrah is the best Canadian wine she’s tasted. If I want great Syrah I’m looking to Southern France and Australia, as will other consumers. Producers need to focus on doing something well, for instance what comes to mind when you think of the Willamette Valley in Oregon? Pinot Noir of course. Mendoza, Argentina? Malbec. Marlborough, New Zealand? Sauvignon Blanc and Pinot Noir. Napa Valley? Cabernet Sauvinon.

So what types of grapes do I think have a future in Niagara? Well, in addition to Chardonnay I will be watching out for solid examples of Cabernet Franc, Baco Noir, Riesling and Gewürztraminer. Thanks to Le Clos Jordanne I will also be keeping a close eye on the development of Pinot Noir in Ontario as well, more on that later.

One last point on over pricing. With the exception of tasting tours around Niagara I don’t buy much wine from Niagara. The reason for my abstinence has more to do with pricing than lack of pride in the wines of my home province. The quality to price ratio is often not favourable and if I have to choose between spending big bucks on a lovely Barolo or a decent but over oaked smoky attempt at a Bordeaux styled wine, well I’m going to stick with the Barolo. Sure there are plenty of people willing to waste large sums of money buying these wines from the winery, but wines should not be priced by what a few select buyers are willing to pay. I think a lot of producers have made the mistake of marketing to the well-healed customer with no palate or idea what a ‘mare-lot’ is supposed to taste like. The price should be dependant on the quality. There are some wineries that are getting the point thankfully, and I hope they will not always be the minority.

Labels:

Saturday, November 10, 2007

Daniel Lenko Estate Winery – Niagara Wine Tour 2007 Part 2

This visit was interesting enough that I thought I’d separate it out from the rest of the Niagara wine tour notes. After hearing numerous good things in the media and from family about this winery I decided to see what the fuss was all about.

This couldn’t be more the antithesis of the slick commercial operations in Niagara. Unless you’re looking for the sign you will likely drive by without noticing the place, as I have done numerous times. This winery may have been somewhat under the radar, but it has developed a loyal following and I’m sure Jancis Robinson’s review of the 2002 Syrah hasn’t hurt much (Robinson said it was the best Canadian red she has tasted). You won’t find it on the Ontario Wine Route map either since Daniel Lenko prefers to skip the steep fees and market his wines by developing a reputation and word of mouth. You can find directions to the winery on the winery website http://www.daniellenko.com/.

Lenko greeted me at the door and welcomed me in to the kitchen/tasting room despite the fact I was there before the official opening time. I enjoyed talking wine with him and his strong opinions and straight talking nature made for many laughs and insights. When asked what he thought of Gamay he responded “Not fit for human consumption… have you ever had a good Gamay from Ontario?” Pinot Noir and Cabernet Sauvignon also had their turn on the block, although he does make both he won’t be planting more anytime soon.

Lenko, who is also the viticulturalist, keeps yields to a paltry 2 tons/acre. He also owns some of the oldest vines in Niagara. Quality definitely comes before quantity here, as well as a particular marketing sense as I was to learn. My visit was refreshing and I must give kudos to Daniel for being a good host.

Some wines are only available by the case and a lot of the wines are already sold out. There is no tasting fee (as it should be).

2005 Unoaked Chardonnay
Quite fruity and the 6 moths the wine spent on the lees comes through with extra body. I’m told this wine did not undergo malo-lactic fermentation and it has a good balance of acid and fruity character. Mineral, grapefruit and slightly nutty. $19.95 88

2006 Reserve Riesling
Nice slate, peachy, lime, nice balance of mineral and acid with ripe fruit. Lots of fruit, but there is a slightly candied aspect to the fruit which makes this a little less polished (like a lollipop flavour you might find in some cheap Riesling, which I see as a slight flaw in many Rieslings from Niagara or Germany). $19.95 89

2006 White Cabernet
This was a surprise, I wasn’t sure what to expect from Cabernet Franc that had been pressed prior to fermentation, but it was nice sipping. Lots of strawberry and watermelon (don’t think I’ve tasted watermelon in a wine before). Good acid, fruity, a refreshing summer sipper. This isn’t a by-product either, it was made from the same low yield vines and pressed with this end result in mind (which Lenko figured would sell well, and not surprisingly it is). $19.95 89

2006 Viogner
I found this very nutty with some tropical fruit, but mostly pear and bitter lychee nut and spice. The mouthfeel is oily and weighty and coats the palate. I like the texture of this wine but to me the interesting flavours are offset by the bitter finish. $34.95 87

2004 Old Vines Chardonnay (American Oak)
The oak seems a bit green and aggressive, or sappy as Daniel put it. Although American oak is not his first choice Lenko wanted to make the same old vines Chard at a more accessible price than the French oak version. It does have good mouthfeel with caramel toast notes. Shame about the oak. $22.95 86

2004 Old Vines Chardonnay (French Oak)
This is more balanced than the American oak version. It is buttery and has nice vanilla aromas, but is still kind of bland to me. In other words, it’s nice but it would be hard to differentiate it from many other French oaked Chards from Niagara. $29.95 89

2002 Old Vines Chardonnay (French Oak)
For comparison Lenko poured me the 2002 to see how the flavours had integrated. And indeed this wine was more balanced and complex with buttery caramel, butterscotch, smoke, hazelnut, and golden delicious apple. I like the faint smokiness. Maybe the 2004 will come along with some time. $29.95 90

2004 Old Vines Merlot
A bit stemy and green with the barrel toast coming through stronger than I’d like. Lots of vanilla, fall leaves, fine tannins, plum and red cherry. If the barrel toast was a little less I think it would be better, but if you’re not as sensitive to burnt wood as I am you’d probably rate this wine higher. $29.95 89

2004 Cabernet Franc
There is some smoky oak, but not as much as the Merlot, slightly perfumy, sweet strawberry, tobacco leaf, and grippy tannins. Great concentration and it lacks the greenness that can plague Ontario Cab Franc. May improve with some clear time. $24.95 89+

2004 Signature Chardonnay
This was my favourite wine of the tasting. Lenko mentioned peat smoke, but I noticed this more with the Old Vines Chard. Well balanced new oak lending some vanilla with mineral, citrus, and apple notes. The mouthfeel is round and the finish is very long with persistent suave pear and apple flavours. The fruit is juicy and the length and quality of the finish make for a powerful and distinctive wine. Strangely enough the wording on the website is similar to mine “…aged in French oak for 18 months, its depth, power, viscosity and complexity are unmatched” despite Lenko having said nothing of the sort to me – after tying the wine I can say he isn’t lying. $39.95 92

Lenko definitely has a solid line up, all his wines show the ripeness or the fruit he uses (thanks to low yields all the grapes reach maturity) and almost all have a silky texture. The only disappointments were the Viogner and American oaked Old Vines Chardonnay, but overall I was impressed and without a doubt I will be keeping an eye on the Chardonnay he produces.

Labels:

Saturday, November 03, 2007

Niagara Wine Tour 2007 – Part 1

This exploration of Niagara’s wines took place over two days; the first day delved a little more into the Niagara on the Lake region since previous tasting tours have focused more on the wineries of Niagara’s Bench west of St. Catharines (mainly Beamsville Bench and Twenty Mile Bench appellations). By Niagara on the Lake I am referring to the Niagara Lakeshore, Niagara River, and Four Mile Creek appellations. Whether these specific appellation designations actually mean anything yet is up for debate. That said, I have noticed some difference in the wines mostly in relation to the vineyard’s proximity to the Escarpment or Lake.

Overall there were not many standout wines on the first day and the tasting bars were crowded with bicycle and bus tours. If you want to avoid the crowds it’s probably better to stick to the Bench on busy weekends. Reif was particularly crowded and there was a line up at the bar, which was pouring very few of their good wines, so we didn’t bother sticking around.

This is the 1st of 3 parts.

Strewn
A fairly large complex that has a restaurant and cooking school in addition to the tasting bar and shop. I’m not a fan of the layout, but at least the wine was good. $0.50 for regular level, $3 for ‘Terroir’ samples.

2005 Terroir Cabernet Franc
Nice green slightly stemy/leafy notes and tobacco, good varietal nose. Very tart and slightly watery; the lack of extract doesn’t balance the acid out. Macintosh apple, pomegranate and strawberry add character to the nose. This might be better with some food. $23 87

2001 Terroir Cabernet Franc
This is riper and more mouth filling than the 2005 with black fruits, richer tobacco leaf, light chocolate and smoke with only faint green notes. It also has less acid and is rounder than the 2005. Solid and unusually rich, but overpriced in my opinion (I’d rather spend the $ on a nice Barolo). $65 90

Lailey Vineyard
This is very close to the touristy main strip of Niagara on the Lake and a minute away from some great views of the Niagara River. The small tasting bar didn’t easily accommodate the bicycle tour hoards. $1-2 for samples.

2006 Dry Riesling
Very floral lily like aromas, green apple, and candy peach/nectarine. There is a sweet edge to the nose but this isn’t the case once you’ve taken a sip, very tart with a sharp greenness that detracts from the overall impression. $19.95 87

2005 Pinot Noir
Vanilla and a little caramel with cherry, strawberry and slightly smoky oak. There is a bit of greenery and earth too. Lacks character on the palate (watery) and the finish is astringent. May improve a bit with a year or two in the bottle. $24.95 86+

Marynissen Estates

The smell in the tasting room reminds me of a cottage and it is way too small to accommodate the tour bus mob. Not my favourite tasting room. The first sample of the Cabernet/Merlot stunk of sulphur (which the staff were oblivious to)! $0.50/sample.

2004 Cabernet Sauvignon
Ridiculously herbaceous and green. Loaded with dill pickle, red fruit, leather, cured meat, and a pine cleaner like note. Possibly a flawed bottle, but I doubt a good bottle would be any less green. $29 78-82

2002 Cabernet/Merlot

This is herbaceous as well but at least has some ripe fruit to compensate. Plum, red fuit, nutty wood and a little meaty with sweet tannins on the finish. $14.95 87

Flat Rock Cellars
Finally we leave the crowds of Niagara on the Lake for the less crowded Bench wineries. The picturesque tasting room is perched on a hill with great views of the vineyard and Lake Ontario. Around $1/tasting.

2006 Nadja’s Vineyard Riesling
Peach, coconut, green apple with crisp mineral nose. The acidity is piercing all the way through to the finish which has a citrus (lime/grapefruit) and green mango character. The acidity is too much to enjoy sipping it by itself; I’d prefer this wine with some food. After the tasting I read Stimmell’s review in the Star, he gives it 91 and noted floral elements (which are not pronounced to me). $19.95 89

2006 Gewürztraminer
Typical lychee and faint roses with banana peel make for a pleasant nose, but the finish is very bitter (lychee nut) and the richness of good examples of this varietal is missing. Not that it was hideous, but I gulped the rest of the glass to avoid tasting it much more. $18.95 86

Malivoire
As you drive up the hill you are greeted by a steel canopied building that has a utilitarian feel about it. The winery uses a gravity fed design and the spacious tasting room has a nice view of the vats. $5 for a flight of 4-5.

2005 Chardonnay
Not oaky, nice mineral, stone fruits, apple, good mouthfeel, toast and lime marmalade. The finish is clean but a bit bitter. $22 89

2004 Moira Vineyard Chardonnay
Malolactic fermentation and more oak than the 2005 Chardonnay, but it is not overdone. Butterscotch, toast, lemon rind, limestone with a pleasantly round mouthfeel. I like the balance of oak to the acid and fruit. $36 90

2006 Gewürztraminer
Riper than Flat Rock’s version in the same year. Ripe lychee, mango and an interesting fruity black tea like nuance. There is some structure and body in the mouth finishing with a little nutty spice. This would be great with some Pad Thai. $25.80 90

2005 Gamay
This Gamay has some oak time and it shows with cloves and vanilla with some strawberry fruitiness. Interesting, but not my preference (then again very few Gamays are), as my score reflects. $16 86

2004 Moira Vineyard Pinot Noir
Good earthy beetroot and cherry Pinot character, and it even has some light Pinot perfume (violets). As good as it is on the nose the palate fell a little short, bitter and a touch acidic. David Lawrason (Wine Access) gave it 4½ stars out of 5 noting cherry-raspberry, floral notes, dried herbs, chocolate and spice. $42 88

Puddicombe Estate
The winery is only a portion of the farm and it has a rustic Ontario farm feel (think candied apples, pumpkins, and hay rides). Not a sleek modern place, but it is free of pretension and the prices that afflict more than a few wineries in Niagara.

2004 Riesling Reserve
Very nice petrol (more pronounced than any other Riesling tasted during the tour), mineral, and lemon drop. A bit candied, but it is the best value of any wine tasted from any of the wineries. $13.20 88

2004 Baco Noir Reserve
Very pungent nose of vegetation, green stems, sour preserved plum, and fruity vinegar. This wine is very ‘in you face’ as our host noted, and strangely I kind of like it for that. It certainly lacks refinement, but what a whack to the senses. Pow! It’s almost like someone toasted some fall leaves and filtered the wine thought it. It is horrendously disjointed in the mouth with sour and sweet notes and a weird savoury taste. Verging on offensive, but I love the smell (if only for its novelty). $11.20 76

Part 2 coming soon! Part 2 will cover Daniel Lenko Estates Winery.

Labels:

Thursday, August 17, 2006

Niagara Wine Tour July 2006



This was my second tour through the Niagara region to do tastings at wineries I didn’t get to the first time and see what the newly released vintages had to offer. Overall I was not as impressed with the wines as I was last time, but it was still a fun experience.

I will list the wines tasted by winery.

Thirty Bench
Our first stop on the tour. There are complimentary tastings, but if you want to try the whole line in a structured tasting it’s $10. I thought that although the wines were good they were overpriced.

2005 Riesling (Beamsville Bench) – Lots of grapefruit and clean citrus. Despite a modest 11.4% alcohol it seems too hot on the nose and palate. Quite fruity, maybe some slate. $18 G-VG (my tasting buddy was not fond of it at all).

2002 Benchmark Blend Red – A medium toast on the barrels, peppery (green and black), a little too green for me, not a lot of tannin. Unripe blackberry and cherry. $25 VG-G

2002 Benchmark Reserve Pinot Noir – Earthy vegetation, beetroot, a touch stemy (bitter greenness from the grape stems), nice concentration for an Ontario Pinot, but pricey. $50 VG

Angels Gate
Almost right across the street from Thirty Bench. There is also a restaurant with a nice patio overlooking the vineyard. 4 complimentary tastings and friendly staff when I was there.

2005 Riesling – A little lees, clean and light, citrus and green apple. There seems to be a slight oxidation (perhaps from the bottle being open too long). $13.95 G

2005 Gewürzstraminer – Tons of lychee! It is unmistakable in the aroma and on the palate. Good mouth feel; thick and oily almost. Kind of one dimensional, though one of the more interesting wines of the day. $15.95 VG

2004 Cabernet Franc – Touch of woody tobacco, orange rind, a little toasty, a bit spicy and full in the mouth. $18.95 VG

2003 Cabernet Sauvignon – Honestly I don’t notice much difference from the Cab Franc other than some cassis. $19.95 G-VG

Vineland Estates
Picturesque winery with a nice tasting bar and restaurant. 50¢ for a non-reserve tasting, $2+ for a reserve which is waived with a wine purchase.

2004 St. Urban Riesling – Quite a bit of acidity, lemony mineral and crisp, though I would not expect this in a Riesling I think there is some gooseberry too. $20 VG-G

2004 Pinot Noir Reserve – Very strong strawberry and rhubarb. I was told that due to the previous vintage selling out so quickly they released this a little early since it was drinking well; I agree, it’s young but good. Maybe some mint in there too. It’s perfumed, not smoky, with a velvety mouthfeel. Best red of the day. $40 VG-E

2004 Cabernet-Merlot Reserve – Barnyard and stale smoke, it smells like an old wood church. I’m not sure what’s going on here, the wine seems ok otherwise. There is some red fruit. $40 G-F

Creekside Estate
Small tasting bar, looks like a little patio to get some grub too. $2 Reserve, $1 estate. The wines I tried had amazing extract for Ontario reds, I was most impressed in this respect.

2002 Merlot Reserve – a little bitter from all that time in oak (23 months), light toast, it gets better with air. It is quite concentrated and full bodied with notes of plum and currant. Something slightly sharp in the nose (minor bottle flaw probably). $25 VG-G

2001 Signature Grand Meritage – Smoky, slightly stemy, and also heavily oaked. There is a touch of herbaciousness, but overall not very interesting to me. The plus is the good extract and body. Give this wine time in a decanter before serving. I liked it better than the Merlot. $34.95 VG

Stratus
I admire the effort they have put in to make this winery energy efficient, more people should follow their lead. The design around the bar is open and well lit. They also had some of the most impressive wines of the day. What I didn’t like was the slightly pretentious air and ridiculous tasting fees ($4 individual - baah! and $10 for 3 or more if they are feeling generous), you even get a receipt.

2002 Riesling – Beeswax, honeysuckle, mineral, citrus, and healthy petrol, all backed by balanced acidity. Very Germanic in style, closer to great German Riesling than any Ontario wine I’ve had so far. The most complex and luscious white of the day. Almost worth the $26. VG-E

2002 Stratus White – Don’t call it a blend, it’s an ‘assemblage’ of 6 separately vinified varieties you know. It has a complex perfume that you would expect given all the varieties used, I think I sense some Gewürtz and Sauv Blanc. Overall quite floral with some tangerine, and interestingly bubble gum too. It’s complex but didn’t blow me away or anything. Under $30 might be more reasonable. 91 from Wine Access $38 VG

2002 Merlot – Smokey, green bell and black pepper, cumin (both tasters noted this, surprising). Nice mouthfeel, decent extract and not bitter. Quite standard, like a lot of other upper end Ontario Merlot (save the cumin bit). $55 VG

2002 Riesling Icewine – There is honey, candied apricots, petrol, and a strong whiff of raisins. Amazing oily mouthfeel, it is sweet and heavy yet evaporates off the tongue leaving a very satisfied look on this tasters face! Spectacular. The only fault I can find is the over raisiny element reminds me of grade school lunch (but that’s just me). Best of the day, and nice value for an icewine this good. $37 E-VG

Jackson-Triggs
Busy wine bar which partly explains the poor service (maybe because I look young), but even in the empty reserve tasting room it took way too long before someone came over and acknowledged us. Proprietors Reserve (PR) – free, Proprietors Grand Reserve (PGR) ~$3 ea.

2005 Gewürzstraminer PR – Fresh lychee with overtones of rotten fruit and spice. Lacks a bit of body (unlike the one from Angels Gate). Decent value $10.90 G

2003 Meritage PR– Like every other red we tried almost; i.e. smoke and a touch of steminess. There is some cherry and decent acidity with a nice finish. Good for the money – if you want a marginally better Ontario red you will have to pay much more. $13.85 G-VG

2004 Delaine Vinyard Chardonnay PGR – Light oak, biscuit/popcorn, fresh citrus and green apple. Nothing special for me. Around $19 G

That’s a wrap for now. I hope these reviews help someone find something they like or decide which wineries they might visit.

Labels:

Saturday, March 11, 2006

Niagara Wine Tour (Oct 2005)




Living so close to a quality wine growing region is definitely a privilege that I was eager to take advantage of. I visited seven wineries and tried twenty-seven wines, which is probably a practical limit because after the last winery my taste buds were not as sharp and doing more would have meant rushing.

Small picutes on the top are of Château des Charmes (left) and Lakeview (right).

Here are my notes by winery:

Peninsula Ridge (largest picture)
4 tastings = $2, ice wine tasting = $2 ea.

2004 Sauvignon Blanc – green apple, grapefruit, touch green tomato, bright with good acid. Considered by some to be the one of the best Sauvignon Blancs in Ontario. $18.95 VG

2003 Inox Chardonnay – I could swear there’s some oak at first, but upon closer inspection (and from the staff) this wine is so rounded not from oak but from malo-lactic fermentation. Touch of fruit (peach) and mineral, creamy too. $19.95 VG-E

2002 Arcanum – licorice, blackberry, smoky oak and a touch of spice. Not the greatest Value though. $29.95 VG-E

2001 Cabernet Sauvignon Reserve – Dill pickles! Plum and smoke with sour red fruit. Ok but not what I expect from a Sauv’. $24.95 G-VG

2001 Cabernet Franc Icewine – ripe raspberry and strawberry jam, honey, good nose, very well balanced sugar/acid. Nice strawberry jam finish with nice tannins. $54.95 E

Lakeview Cellars
Tastings are free, and the staff was quite friendly.

2003 Baco Noir – the 2002 garnered much praise, the 2003 was also quite nice. Green, a touch stemy, slight barrel toast, pomegranate, good varietal character but not my preference. $19.95 G-VG

2003 Pinot Noir Reserve – beetroot, earth, a bit watery for me, I like the Baco (above) more. $24.95 G

2003 Riesling – light petrol, candied lime peel and pineapple nose, lemon drop taste, great acidity and value. $10.95 VG

2004 Pinot Grigio Reserve – candy, melon, very different but bland. $? G-F

2002 Cabernet Franc – cayenne, green bell pepper, tobacco smoke. $? G

Cave Springs
Around $1-2 per tasting, I didn’t like the service or atmosphere there.

2004 Gewürztraminer – very light lychee nut, a touch floral, light citrus, a touch sweet with a bitter finish. Not super for a Gewurzt. $ 17.95 VG-G

2003 Chardonnay Reserve – I’m told it was aged in Hungarian Oak 15 months; the oak is not overwhelming, but there isn’t enough fruit and acid to balance it out. Good mouth feel and finish. $19.95 VG

Henry of Pelham
Nice cottage/cellar like feel. A $2 donation to Brock University’s oenology program gets you 4 tastings. The tasting bar wasn’t designed for short people.

2004 Reserve Chadonnay – fresh clean nose with buttery notes of oak. Equally as good as the Cave Springs Chard, but much cheaper. $13.95 VG

2004 Barrel Fermented Chardonnay – creamy oak, maple syrup, and coconut. Great mouth feel. If you like more heavily oaked Chard take this one over the Reserve.
$19.95 VG-E

2004 Dry Rose – raisin and strawberry, but unfortunately watery with a chemical taste/smell that reminds me of poor homemade wine. F

2004 Baco Noir – smoky, raspberry, not green. Ok, but Lakeview’ was better. $12.95 G

2002 Unfiltered Cabernet-Merlot – A touch of smoke and strong green pepper aroma. Ok but too green. For me the price is way above the quality. $29.95 F-G

1998 Unfiltered Cabernet-Merlot – touch of pepper, a hint of greenness, meaty (reminds me of meat marinating in a sweet soy sauce), full bodied, and balanced but not my style (especially at this price). $50 VG

Niagara College Teaching Winery
A small informal shop, around $1 per tasting (which is waived if you buy a bottle).

2003 Warren Classic Chardonnay – Amazingly smooth and round mouth feel. It smells and tastes like vanilla ice cream with a hint of apple sauce on it. There is some acidity to balance it out, but it’s not really a fruity wine. If you hate oak forget about this wine; if you like creamy oak you’ll love it! $27.95 E

2004 Canadian Oak Chardonnay – Creamy butterscotch, coconut, and maple syrup are balanced with more fresh acidity than the Warren Classic. Not as good mouth feel, but it’s a much better value then the Warren. $18 – 19 E-VG

2004 Pinot Noir – white pepper, light pomegranate, beetroot, lacks body (too light even for a Pinot IMHO). $21.95 VG-G

Château des Charmes
The mansion is a tourist magnet and the wine bar was crowded. Service was so-so. $1 per tasting.

2003 Chardonnay Musqué – Kind of like a Riesling with some Viognier mixed in: clean, pale, lightly floral (honeysuckle), refreshing acidity (it would do well with a wide range of food). $ 15.95 VG-G

2004 Riesling – A perfumed floral nose (jasmine) with very light lemon and honey. Hardly any mineral elements (must be grown farther from the lake), but with a nice balance of acid and sugar. Great, but nothing distinguishing. $15.95 VG-E

2002 Merlot – Overly charred wood hits you in the nose right away, yet it does have a full, if slightly rough, mouthfeel. It tastes better than it smells: plum, cherry and a touch of greenness. Not my preference but good. $25 VG

Thomas and Vaughn
Opens later than other wineries, so save it for last. No tasting fee.

2004 Baco Noir – Very green, slightly stemy, tamrind nose. Rather mild on the palate and smooth if a tad watery. $11.95 G-VG

2000 Cabernet Franc Estate Reserve – This has lots of oak and some laid back fruit (plum skin and berry). Thankfully not overly smokey but a bit too light and not distinctly Cab Franc to me. However, Tony Aspler gives it 4 out of 5 stars and also notes pencil lead…so my opinion doesn’t mean this wine might not be great for someone else, just not me. $26.95 VG

1999 Vidal Icewine – Pure Vidal on the nose, a hint of cooked strawberry, canned lychee, apricot. It’s not overly sweet and syrupy, not some much due to balancing acidity but a lower sugar content than most Vidal icewine. Nothing too complex, but the deal they had going was a steal: 2 for $24! VG-G

Summary:
In general I’ve always found I like Ontario white wine more than red, and my ratings probably reflect this. I’ve found that the reds are usually a little underripe and lacking concentration. But what I hate most are the reds that have been aged in overly toasted barrels, the resulting smokiness can obliterate the fruit and subtle nuances of the wine. I think this over toasting is often done to cover up the lack of ripeness and add complexity that the grapes could not provide, but that’s just a hypothesis. Another problem is price, when Ontario reds are good they tend to be way too expensive (it’s easy to find the same quality from other countries for far less money).
I think red wine has a long way to go in Ontario, but things are always improving. I’m sure I’ll have more to say on this topic in a future post.

Labels: